Somewhere in Napa Valley, someone could be on a waiting list for a wine they may never have tasted. They do not know the price. They have been told, in plain language, that there is no firm timeframe and that a place opens only when someone else drops off. And they may keep their name on the list. That is a pricing page with no price on it.

Several wineries sit at the other end of the spectrum: a clean grid of bottle counts, shipment prices and discounts anyone can read in a minute. The distance between those two pages is where wine club pricing gets interesting. This piece reads the published club pages of several wineries and shows how three different models turn the same grapes into very different memberships.

$1,610
Average Shipment, Cakebread Cabernet Club 12 (Four a Year)
$100
Low-End Price Per Bottle at Every Pine Ridge Club Size (Our Math)
48
Bottles a Year in Cakebread’s 12-Bottle Clubs
5%
Share of Williams Selyem Wines Placed Outside the List, at Full Retail

Model One: Sell by the Bottle

The simplest ladder prices volume. Three tiers ship three times a year: a four-bottle tier at $300 to $375 a shipment, eight bottles at $500 to $610, and twelve bottles at $750 to $925, per Rutherford Hill. Release savings rise from 15 percent to 20 percent, shipping goes from $20 to free, and the top tier adds unlimited tastings and priority access to limited releases, per Rutherford Hill. Do the division on the $300 to $375 small tier and the per-bottle price runs from $75 to $93.75, per Rutherford Hill. On the $750 to $925 large tier it runs $62.50 to $77, per Rutherford Hill. Buy more, pay less per bottle, get more access. The page carries no pricing date.

Matthiasson follows the same logic with two sizes shipped in April and October. Six bottles are $425 plus tax and $59 flat-rate shipping, about $71 a bottle before shipping, per Matthiasson. Twelve are $795 plus tax with free ground shipping, about $66 a bottle, per Matthiasson. Members take 10 percent off additional wine at the small tier and 15 percent at the large one, per Matthiasson.

Model Two: Sell the Experience, Hold the Price

Pine Ridge takes a different route. Its club page lists three sizes shipped four times a year, and the math comes out flat: $300 to $330 for three bottles, $600 to $660 for six and $1,200 to $1,320 for twelve, each plus tax, per Pine Ridge. That is $100 to $110 a bottle at every level, per Pine Ridge’s published prices. Everyone gets the same 20 percent release discount, per Pine Ridge. What changes is the experience: the 12-bottle tier covers estate tastings for up to six people and two tickets to an on-site event, while the smaller tiers cover four, per Pine Ridge. There is no fee to join.

The lesson is that a tier does not have to be a volume discount. When price per bottle stays level, the member is paying for access, not savings. It is the same idea that separates a golf club’s full and limited memberships.

The Private Club Journal, weekly

Get exclusive insights delivered weekly

Join 68,100+ club leaders and industry professionals. +3.1% this month

Model Three: Sell by the Wine

Cakebread’s club page sorts by what is in the box. Its Baker’s Club averages $615 for 12 bottles and $335 for six, per Cakebread. The Classic Red Club averages $923 and $558, per Cakebread. The Cabernet clubs average $1,610 and $805, per Cakebread. Each ships four times a year, and the page labels these as averages before taxes and delivery. The 12-bottle Cabernet Club works out to about $134 a bottle, per Cakebread’s $1,610 average. That is roughly two and a half times the Baker’s Club’s $51, per Cakebread’s $615 average.

Price Per Bottle in 12-Bottle Clubs (Our Division of Published Prices)
Cakebread Cabernet Club (average)
$134
Pine Ridge (low end of range)
$100
Cakebread Classic Red Club (average)
$77
Matthiasson 12 Bottle
$66
Rutherford Hill (low end of range)
$63
Cakebread Baker’s Club (average)
$51

Per-bottle figures are our division of published shipment prices, rounded, before tax and shipping. The pages carry no pricing date, so confirm current pricing. Bars are scaled to the largest value shown.

The List Without a Price

Then there are the wineries that do not run a club in this sense at all. Screaming Eagle’s FAQ sends visitors to a waiting list and says: “Unfortunately, we cannot give you a firm timeframe.” It adds that a place opens only when an active member drops off the list. The page lists no prices.

Williams Selyem in Sonoma publishes more of the mechanics on its acquire page. Wait times typically range from a few months to a year, per Williams Selyem, and members are invited to order twice a year, in spring and fall. Wines are allocated to list members based on longevity, purchase history, referrals and loyalty, and allocations are neither reserved nor guaranteed, per Williams Selyem. The list carries no fees and no auto-shipments. About 95 percent of wines are sold directly to list members, and the remaining five percent is placed with select restaurants and merchants at full retail, per Williams Selyem. Benefits grow with tenure, and the page lists no prices.

Here the price is the wait, and the rules reward behavior: loyalty, history and referrals. Harlan Estate’s homepage, for what it is worth, showed only a mailing address and contact details when we opened it, so we cannot say what its list requires.

What This Means for Your Club

These are our recommendations, built from the pages above.

Decide what a tier is for. Volume, experience and varietal each build a different ladder. Our earlier guide to wine club tier architecture covers the framework, and the pages above show it in use.

Show the per-bottle math. Members do the division anyway. A page that does it for them, as Rutherford Hill’s grid nearly does, looks confident.

If you allocate, say how. Williams Selyem’s list of longevity, purchase history, referrals and loyalty is a rule members can act on. Our look at fall allocation and club acquisition shows the season to use it.

Give members something to attend. Pine Ridge includes caves and tastings at a flat per-bottle price. A club that runs a harvest dinner can do the same.

Winery Club Pricing FAQ

How much does a winery wine club cost?

On the pages we read, shipments run from an average of $275 for a six-bottle white club at Cakebread to an average of $1,610 for a 12-bottle Cabernet club, per Cakebread. Pine Ridge lists shipments of up to $1,320, per Pine Ridge. Most pages exclude tax and shipping.

Do bigger tiers cost less per bottle?

Sometimes. Rutherford Hill and Matthiasson charge less per bottle at the larger tier, while Pine Ridge holds the price level and changes the perks.

What is a wine allocation list?

It is a list of buyers invited to purchase limited releases. Williams Selyem says it allocates based on longevity, purchase history, referrals and loyalty, and that allocations are not guaranteed.

Why don’t some wineries publish prices?

The Screaming Eagle page and the Harlan Estate homepage we opened publish none, and we cannot speak to their reasons.

How We Did This

We opened each winery’s own club page and recorded what it said. Wineries have an interest in how they present themselves, and none of the pages carries a pricing date, so prices may have changed. Per-bottle figures are our division of published shipment prices, using the low end where a range is shown. We did not estimate prices for wineries that publish none.

If your team is shaping a wine program or member offer, Private Club Marketing has worked only with private clubs since 2009 and brings that focus to country club marketing. Talk with us.

Free Download

The 2026 Private Club Benchmark Report

The membership, amenity, and pricing data reshaping private clubs — from a 1,200-club analysis. Enter your details and we'll send it to your inbox.

Private Club Marketing Editorial Team

Editorial Team

Private Club Marketing

Private Club Marketing’s editorial and research is conducted in conjunction with its advisory and development team.

View all articles →